13 Comments
User's avatar
Larry A.'s avatar

It’s disappointing to see political assessments like this one that are so incomplete and far from the reality on the ground.  Is the best course to give up any negotiations in the next Congress, and bow to the wishes of Trump even after the mandate against him and his policies that the American people just delivered? 

 Why roll over to take such a bad deal as BAAJA now when it’s the worst version of what could be achievable as law? 

Should we really believe that giving Trump and his administration very broad authority to fast track harmful projects of ALL types (not just energy) while preventing future administrations from reconsidering them even where they were authorized illegally is the only deal possible? This is what the manager’s amendment includes, not just the original draft.   Read the White House press releases - they are salivating at the possibility Democrats could be so weak and gullible as to pass BAAJA now. 

Shouldn’t we at least take the time to work on fixing issues like this in the next Congress?

Next session there is a good chance at veto-proofing something with a much better balance of gives and gets than BAAJA, and a very high chance of something better in at least some areas.  

Melanie Lenart's avatar

Those of you who are enthusiastic about passing this bill are ignoring this: having energy facilities on our public lands will destroy natural systems. The only reason this can claim to be a benefit in a climate equation is because we are not giving our forests, grasslands and other natural systems enough credit for all the hard work they do, including in pulling down carbon dioxide.

So why should we destroy living systems to support artificial ones? We all know the new energy is going for AI data centers. With the latest Nvidia scandal, the chances of an AI bubble are bigger than ever.

The important question is, why are we destroying the living world and decimating future human jobs to support an artificial one?

Brandon Keim's avatar

BAAJA proponents argue that source-agnostic electricity transmission reform, where the bill's potential climate gains would come from, is broadly popular—but also that transmission-specific legislation is inconceivable, even with a Democratic trifecta, and our only choice is to bundle it in *right now* with a laundry list of unrelated industry deregulation wishes that would gut federal environmental law. And we're told that the bad parts can be changed later, because somehow pro-environmental amendments would be possible in a political reality where transmission reform could never pass.

The century's most sweeping environmental regulatory reform was effectively drafted behind closed doors by industry lobbyists, without any participation from environmental, citizen, or tribal groups, and is now being pushed into law without public hearings. That's a rotten foundation on which to build anything.

Jeff Suchon's avatar

Pass this bill NOW. Better now than later. Make another bill later for improvements.

Saving Earth and lives is cumulative.

Earth is a terrible thing to waste.

Lives are a terrible things to waste.

We cannot waste time AGAIN.

Smokey's avatar

Stopped reading when you used the term “dirty" to refer to natural gas generation. It's beneath someone of your stature as a scientist to use such non-sensical loaded shortcuts.

Erik Frederiksen's avatar

I am worried about the increased use of natural gas. From an article a year or two ago in the NY Times about natural gas (which is largely methane): “It takes as little as 0.2 percent of gas to leak to make natural gas as big a driver of climate change as coal, the study found. That’s a tiny margin of error for a gas that is notorious for leaking . . .It can’t be considered a good bridge, or substitute.” And the leaks are far higher than that. According to the IPCC recently we don’t have decades to alter course substantially, just years in which to have a chance to avoid the worst impacts. We cannot be building out more fossil fuel burning plants if we wish a chance at sustaining organized human life.

Robert Wegeng's avatar

I’m not against reducing regulatory delay, but isn’t this characterization -- that we can’t reduce CO2 emissions without it (the BAAJA) -- a large overstatement? Over the period from 2000 to 2025, the annual CO2 emissions by the USA electrical power sector were reduced by about 35% through the combination of reduced coal consumption, greater use of natural gas & nuclear, and (to a lessor though meaningful extent) buildout of renewable wind and solar.

The added real cost to electricity, including the ITC and PTC tax credits has equated to about $75 per tonne of CO2 emission reduced, which is large enough to matter but, on the other hand, is obviously still reasonable. Bottom line is that a 35% reduction in just 25 years shows that we are already succeeding in affordably reducing CO2 emissions from electrical power generation. And we’re getting better at it, too.

Let’s now affordably accelerate further by continuing what’s already working and by bringing in additional renewable natural gas, H2 and modular fuel cells, and plug-in vehicles (including BEVs and PHEVs), and by re-extending the qualifying date for the Clean Hydrogen Production Tax Credits to 2033.

We can clearly get to declining worldwide CO2 emissions -- and peak atmospheric CO2 levels -- within just a few decades.

Thomas Tibor's avatar

This article sounds reasonable to me, not having researched the bill in depth. The fact that it can speed up clean energy projects is a big plus. It should create the “facts on the ground” needed for progress. Pass now, gain credibility among the public when it sees stuff happening and use that credibility to get better legislation in the future. Thoughts?

Melanie Lenart's avatar

Thomas, this bill would allow our government to more rapidly tear down living systems in our public lands to support AI data centers. That’s the problem with it.

Jeff Suchon's avatar

Congress is anew in January for the environment

Thomas Tibor's avatar

The only concern I have is whether the Democrats can pass a bill that is veto-proof. What is the threshold for overriding a Trump veto? Can a new, better bill achieve that?

Jeff Suchon's avatar

Be safe. Pass this one and get something. Trump in 27 is either a more rabid dog or might wimp with his tail between his legs. I really believe ( I totally knew he is/was a madman ) he is finally going to wimp out in 27 )

Jeff Suchon's avatar

Something needed for other things now is better than nothing now and no other things later

A new bill can be done later with even more yet to be perceived improvements in a yet more receptive Congress.

A bird in the hand…