Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Brian Smith's avatar

You've convinced me - emissions from electric generation today are lower than they would have been if solar and wind had not increased over the last 20 years. I'm glad the discussion seems to have moved beyond rapid, deep decarbonization regardless of cost.

From a real-world perspective, I think the more interesting question is, "How much are people (and governments) willing to pay for emissions reductions in terms of higher energy prices and lower reliability?" A related question would be "How much would solar and wind have increased, absent requirements and subsidies?"

On the first, I think the answer is "Not as much as they have been paying." I think higher energy prices, particularly for electricity, have contributed significantly to economic stagnation in most of Europe, and have reduced growth and prosperity in the US. The economic consequences have contributed to the rise of right-wing populism in both regions. In poorer areas, I think people and governments would have eagerly chosen less expensive energy sources that could provide more energy to facilitate economic growth, if they hadn't been coerced by conditions imposed by international aid and financial institutions.

This implies that the answer to the related question is "Not nearly as much as they have."

I expect China would have pursued wind and solar development, because China wants to reduce dependence on imported fuel. Whether this makes good economic sense is a different question.

Ken Fabian's avatar

Going by personal experience our rooftop solar + batteries provide above 95% of our household energy usage. Even that 5% seems more about... inverters taking advantage of the grid as fast shock absorber for fast switching bigger loads and 'handshaking'.

More than twice what our household uses goes TO the grid. Rather than that energy abundance leading to ever more consumption a lot of the biggest loads are vastly improving in efficiency - heat pumps mostly. Not even Jevon can keep up.

I'll add that 15% of Australia's grid input is already just the leftovers of (privately owned) rooftop PV. Wind and solar farms are pushing it towards 50% RE and batteries are shifting that from 'just daytime' towards anytime.

I think bidirectional EV's will do even more; our very modest sized PV system as it is would run one - for our admittedly frugal usage. But frugal for us is overwhelming abundance for most of the world.

Not all the way there, especially for difficult climates but science, engineering and innovation is awesmacking.

83 more comments...

Ready for more?